An Ontario judge has reserved sentencing for a teenager who pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the fatal stabbing of retired nurse Shahnaz Pestonji during an attempted carjacking in North York. The Crown and defence are jointly seeking a seven-year youth sentence but disagree over credit for time already spent in custody.

According to Global News court reporting by Catherine McDonald, Ontario Court Justice Rachel Grinberg will deliver her sentencing decision at a later date. The teenager was 14 when Pestonji, 71, was killed on July 17, 2025, and is now 15. He entered his guilty plea on Sept. 10.

An agreed statement of facts described Pestonji loading groceries into her Toyota Corolla outside Iqbal’s food store on Parkway Forest Drive that morning. A witness told police he saw a suspect approach her, heard her scream and saw the suspect stab her in the chest before running away.

Assistant Crown attorney Andrea McPhedran described the killing as “a callous and unduly violent attack.” Surveillance footage shown in court captured the teenager grabbing Pestonji while trying to obtain her keys, then pulling her between two vehicles, where she was stabbed, Global News reported.

Police arrested him in Scarborough on July 20, following a three-day search.

Pestonji had spent 28 years caring for veterans at Sunnybrook Health Centre. She was married for 47 years, had two grown daughters and was a grandmother.

Her family chose not to attend court because it would be too difficult, McPhedran said. Three victim impact statements described their grief.

“She loved dancing. I still enjoy listening to dance music but I don’t dance anymore because the person I dance with is no longer here,” her husband wrote.

The proposed sentence would consist of four years in custody followed by three years of community supervision. McPhedran said seven years is the maximum youth sentence for second-degree murder.

The Crown argued the sentence should begin on the sentencing date without credit for pre-sentence custody, citing rehabilitation and public protection. McPhedran also told the court that the teenager qualifies for an intensive rehabilitative custody and supervision order, involving treatment intended to reduce the risk of further offences.

Sources